追風者PHANTEKS POLAR T6-120 & S5-120 CPU塔式風冷散熱器開箱測試

14410

PAGE 1 評價

PAGE 2 開箱

PAGE 3 配件

PAGE 4 散熱器

PAGE 5 INTEL LGA1700 Z790安裝


背景

CPU塔式散熱器由INTEL不停推高功耗開始慢慢沒落, AMD那邊廂更是笑話, 主因還有風冷散熱技術停滯不前沒有大突破。CPU塔散逐漸變得難以壓制範圍極小(DIE面積)兼極快又極大的功耗波動, 塔式風冷有被CPU AIO一體式水冷取代之勢。那些風冷散熱廠商能夠做的就是把風冷散熱器的價格降下來, 將頂級散熱性能下放。我們可看到那些中國散熱品牌紛紛推出性能強大的百元(RMB)風冷單塔散熱器和二三百元(RMB)的雙塔風冷散熱器, 輕鬆斬殺國際知名大廠動輒五六七八百元的頂級型號。

YUJIHW又再一次收到來自追風者PHANTEKS的最新風冷塔式散熱器(單塔和雙塔)作開箱測試, 感謝香港代理商AMART一直以來的無限量信任和支持。PHANTEKS在風冷散熱器市場中深耕已久, 當年的雙塔PH-TC14PE更與NOCTUA D14和THERMALRIGHT IB-E EXTREME齊名, 但近年可謂毫無新意。在上年年尾PHANTEKS終於再次推出新款風冷塔式散熱器, POLAR系列S5-120(單塔)和T6-120(雙塔)。PHANTEKS以那些中國散熱品牌的新皇牌型號作為目標, 利用國際知名品牌的實力攻佔中低價散熱市場。今日就讓我們帶各位讀者細看這兩款PHANTEKS仍未在全球官網頁面上架的最新PHANTEKS風冷產品。

26-3-2023

測試

 

12900k
gigabyte z790 aorus elite ax rev1.0 (bios f5)
tjmax 115c, 1.375v set, llc low, get 1.236v (socket sense)
open bench, mobo laid down
amibent temp 28c
igpu 4k60hz
prime95 sffts no avx 10mins
hwinfo64 5th-10th mins, enhanced cpu package temp & package power
thermalright tf7 thermal paste
air coolers tested with heatpipes facing up only

 

由於今次測試涉及120MM單塔, 所以我們特意將12900K的電壓降至最低, 並只以P95 SFFTS (NON AVX)作測試。我們未有測試AVX的版本。以下測試除非有特別指明, 否則全是裸跑測試, 兼底板躺平。

 

M25風扇

pwm fan rpm feeling
100% 1980rpm
90% 1830rpm very loud
80% 1690rpm loud
70% 1530rpm good
60% 1370rpm silent
50% 1215rpn
40% 1020rpm
30% 845rpm
20% 675rpm
10% 410rpm
0% 0rpm

 

全速測試, 原裝散熱膏, 原裝風扇。事前我們沒想到S5單塔亦能夠撐住12900K 250W。M25風扇全速太嘈。今時今日已是新一代AIO的世界, 塔散風冷輸到甩褲。

proartist ea5 (tube facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar s5-120 single tower
mobo lied down / vertical rad mobo lied down mobo lied down
thermalright tf7 thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 4.3w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k “”noctua a12x25 pwm 2000rpm”” stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 86c 85c 96c 94c 104c 102c
12900k cpu package power 250w 246w 261w 256w 269w 264w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.248v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise “”54db”” 60db 57db
ambient temp 27.0c 27.3c 27.2c
vrm temp 54c 54c

 


T6-120

測試針對T6雙扇組合上的轉速差異。1500RPM還可以接受, 日常使用建議1000~1500RPM。

proartist ea5 (tube facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south)
mobo lied down / vertical rad mobo lied down mobo lied down mobo lied down
thermalright tf7 thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k “”noctua a12x25 pwm 2000rpm”” stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 1500rpm stock fans 1000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 86c 85c 96c 94c 101c 100c 108c 107c
12900k cpu package power 250w 246w 261w 256w 265w 260w 273w 271w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.248v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise “”54db”” 60db 54db 50db
ambient temp 27.0c 27.3c 27.4c 27.2c
vrm temp 54c 57c 62c

 


 

然後我們嘗試使用S5單塔所提供的次一級散熱膏, 效果的確不如T6所提供的版本。換句話說S5單塔有點可惜了。

proartist ea5 (tube facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south)
mobo lied down / vertical rad mobo lied down mobo lied down
thermalright tf7 thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste phanteks 4.3w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k “”noctua a12x25 pwm 2000rpm”” stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 86c 85c 96c 94c 99c 97c
12900k cpu package power 250w 246w 261w 256w 261w 257w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.248v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise “”54db”” 60db 60db
ambient temp 27.0c 27.3c 27.2c
vrm temp 54c 57c

 

 

PHANTEKS太弱了只敢標5.2W/MK。

phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south)
mobo lied down mobo lied down
stock phanteks 5.2w/mk thermalright tf7 12.8w/mk
stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 2000rpm
max avg max avg
96c 94c 96c 93c
257w 253w 259w 254w
1.236v~1.248v 1.236v~1.236v
24.4c 24.7c

 


 

T6裝上第三把風扇後效果不理想, 看來原來的M25組合已經最佳狀態。由於第三把扇以PULL形式緊貼散熱器鰭片, 噪音急升。

proartist ea5 (tube facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south)
mobo lied down / vertical rad mobo lied down mobo lied down
thermalright tf7 thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k “”noctua a12x25 pwm 2000rpm”” stock fans 2000rpm tripple stock fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 86c 85c 96c 94c 96c 94c
12900k cpu package power 250w 246w 261w 256w 258w 254w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.248v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise “”54db”” 60db 64db (no offset pads for pull fan)
ambient temp 27.0c 27.3c 27.3c
vrm temp 54c 53c

 


 

T6雙扇原廠建議PUSH & PUSH, 即是將風扇掛在吹向鰭片的那一邊。若將風扇安裝成PULL, 噪音上升溫度亦未見有改進。PHANTEKS M25風扇只適合PUSH。

proartist ea5 (tube facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south)
mobo lied down / vertical rad mobo lied down mobo lied down mobo lied down
thermalright tf7 thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k “”noctua a12x25 pwm 2000rpm”” stock fans 2000rpm (push and push) stock fans 2000rpm (push and pull) stock fans 2000rpm (pull and pull)
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 86c 85c 96c 94c 100c 96c 97c 96c
12900k cpu package power 250w 246w 261w 256w 261w 256w 261w 256w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.248v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise “”54db”” 60db 61b (no offset pads for pull fan) 62b (no offset pads for pull fans)
ambient temp 27.0c 27.3c 27.4c 27.5c
vrm temp 54c 56c 54c

 


 

將雙塔T6風扇M25更換至打排專用的高風壓NOCTUA NF-A12X25 PWM, 溫度不降反升。PHANTEKS新塔散需要高風量風扇, M25絕配。

proartist ea5 (tube facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south)
mobo lied down / vertical rad mobo lied down mobo lied down
thermalright tf7 thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k “”noctua a12x25 pwm 2000rpm”” stock fans 2000rpm (push and push) noctua a12x25 pwm fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 86c 85c 96c 94c 100c 98c
12900k cpu package power 250w 246w 261w 256w 264w 259w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.248v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.248v
noise “”54db”” 60db 53db
ambient temp 27.0c 27.3c 27.2C
vrm temp 54c 59c

 

 

1500RPM & 1000RPM的測試。PHANTEKS M25風扇要到1000RPM溫度上才被NOCTUA追平。當然NOCTUA遠比PHANTEKS M25靜。

phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south)
mobo lied down mobo lied down mobo lied down mobo lied down
stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k stock fans 1500rpm noctua a12x25 pwm fans 1500rpm stock fans 1000rpm noctua a12x25 pwm fans 1000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 101c 100c 105c 104c 108c 107c 109c 108c
12900k cpu package power 265w 260w 274w 268w 273w 271w 268w 265w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise 54db 49db 50db 41db
ambient temp 27.4c 27.4c 27.2c 27.2c
vrm temp 57c 65c 62c 67c

 

noctua 1000rpm
phanteks stock fan 1000rpm

 

若將底板棵起, T6風冷雙塔銅管內的液體便失去引力優勢。

proartist ea5 (tube facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south)
mobo lied down / vertical rad mobo lied down mobo placed vertically (upside down)
thermalright tf7 thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k “”noctua a12x25 pwm 2000rpm”” stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 86c 85c 96c 94c 100C 98C
12900k cpu package power 250w 246w 261w 256w 263W 258W
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.248v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236V~1.236V
noise “”54db”” 60db
ambient temp 27.0c 27.3c 27.2C
vrm temp 54c 52C

技嘉超耐久設計名不虛傳


 

以躺平底板使用來說, PHANTEKS T6雙塔的不對稱銅管分佈到底向上還是向下, 都不太重要。

phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing south) phanteks polar t6-120 dual tower (p facing north)
mobo lied down mobo lied down
stock 5.2w thermal paste stock 5.2w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 96c 94c 96c 95c
12900k cpu package power 261w 256w 259w 255w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise
ambient temp 27.3c 27.3C
vrm temp 54c 54c

 


S5-120

以下是S5單塔的測試結果。首先測試S5單塔對於風扇降速的影響。測試結果證明S5單塔醉愛風量。

phanteks polar s5-120 single tower phanteks polar s5-120 single tower phanteks polar s5-120 single tower
mobo lied down mobo lied down mobo lied down
stock 4.3w thermal paste stock 4.3w thermal paste stock 4.3w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 1500rpm noctua a12x25 pwm fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 104c 102c 108c 107c 107c 105c
12900k cpu package power 269w 264w 273w 270w 275w 267w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise 57db 51db 51db
ambient temp 27.2c 27.2c 26.7c
vrm temp 54c 58c 58c
s5 with noctua a12x25 at 2000rpm
stock phanteks m25 fan at 2000rpm

 

若將T6雙塔附送的散熱膏塗上, S5效果更佳。

phanteks polar s5-120 single tower phanteks polar s5-120 single tower
mobo lied down mobo lied down
stock 4.3w thermal paste phanteks 5.2w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 104c 102c 99c 97c
12900k cpu package power 269w 264w 262w 257w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise 57db
ambient temp 27.2c 26.5c
vrm temp 54c 55c

 


 

S5掛雙扇溫度效果有幫助, 但是噪音難頂。

phanteks polar s5-120 single tower phanteks polar s5-120 single tower
mobo lied down mobo lied down
stock 4.3w thermal paste stock 4.3w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k stock fans 2000rpm dual stock fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 104c 102c 100c 98c
12900k cpu package power 269w 264w 264w 258w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise 57db 61db
ambient temp 27.2c 27.2c
vrm temp 54c 52c

 


 

將底板倒掛變為正常直立式機箱設計的狀態, 失去引力優勢的S5竟然沒有受到太大影響, 甚是驚喜。

phanteks polar s5-120 single tower phanteks polar s5-120 single tower
mobo lied down mobo placed vertical (upside down)
stock 4.3w thermal paste stock 4.3w thermal paste
1.236v ~250w 12900k stock fans 2000rpm stock fans 2000rpm
prime95 sffts (no avx) 10mins max avg max avg
12900k cpu package temp 104c 102c 105c 103c
12900k cpu package power 269w 264w 269w 265w
vcore (socket sense) 1.236v~1.236v 1.236v~1.236v
noise 57db
ambient temp 27.2c 27.3c
vrm temp 54c 53c


總結

喜見更多散熱老牌重新找到熱誠再度推出風冷散熱器, 為眾多懼怕AIO漏水的用家帶來更多優質選擇。PHANTEKS POLAR T6-120表現不俗, 但只在躺平狀態下大放異彩, 我們不理解為何官方會將T6的導熱管稱之為抗重力設計。對於現今INTEL主流高階CPU能否被風冷散熱器壓制, 這視乎CPU的電壓有多低及日常使用的軟件/負載是什麼。在日常上網睇片打機的情況下我們看不到為什麼不能選用風冷散熱器, 可是考慮到INTEL NON K CPU在降壓上的性能損失問題, 風冷塔散要生存下來的確困難。INTEL扣具的部份與GLACIER ONE T30 GEN2上的感受差不多, 建議PHANTEKS砍掉重造。

PHANTEKS POLAR S5-120是高一級的PHANTEKS單塔銅底版本, 經測試後我們感到老牌散熱大廠終於歸位, S5-120憑藉出色的抗引力銅管成功壓制250W 12900K(NON AVX), 雖然噪音代價有點太大。PHANTEKS特調的塔散設計明顯獨愛風量型風扇, 雖然PHANTEKS不認, 可惜現時各品牌頂級的風扇主要都是以風壓為優先, PHANTEKS附送降速線其來有自。

關於M25-120風扇的串連接駁設計內的第三針處理, 我們不建議在通電情況下拔插M25風扇。建議PHANTEKS直接完整移除風扇串連部份的第三針。將S5-120的散熱膏升級, 為T6-120加入長螺批, 要把對手殺下馬來應該不難。

客觀地說售價是這些新風冷塔散的唯一優勢, 加上風冷本身不會漏水損壞其他硬件, 客路甚廣。又有多少人24/7燒P95 AVX。PHANTEKS POLAR T6-120現售$310HKD而PHANTEKS POLAR S5-120現售$235HKD, 由代理商AMART提供五年保養。

 

S5頂部黑色鰭片亦有作用